Hazrat Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq By Shaykh Mufti Taqi Usmani A FAMOUS BOOK WRITTEN IN DEFENCE OF HAZRAT MUAVIA [R.A] Hazrat Ameer Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Rivayaat By Shaykh Muhammad. Ameer Muawiya Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq Author Mufti Taqi Usmani. May Click to Download Click to Read on Scribd. Post a Comment. For More Islamic Books For More Islamic Books Visit For More I.
|Published (Last):||23 August 2009|
|PDF File Size:||4.85 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||14.44 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
I hope you get my point. If someone blames our father, should we accept his accusations without any assessment? Many thanks for your kind words and comments about my books.
Whatever is the opinion of Sunnis, Shias or Khawarij on such issues, it is no more than a theory based on doubtful reports because Sunni reports are not acceptable to Shia and vice versa. We also know that all such people disguised themselves in mainstream Muslims.
I appreciate that you study the history. The book is available at the following links: If you study the history of Tabari for such years, you’ll find people in the Sanad of all negative reports about the companions.
Hazrat Ameer Muawiya R-A – [PDF Document]
Only that person will reach at a real conclusion who was present at that occasion and bears eyewitness of an incident. The approach of Tabari was to compile all the narrations whether authentic or not in a chronological order.
I hope you ll not think that I am a Shia because ‘I am not’. All those who accepted their caliphate will also be charged automatically as they accepted corrupt rulers. If some Sahaba had something wrong, Allah will not ask us about that but if they were really acquitted from that, we will be held responsible in front of Allah for believing in reports transmitted through doubtful channels.
Thank you very much for answering me. And then he tried to convert the muslim khilafat into malookiat. We should keep a good view Husn Zann about all the companions and leave the matter of their internal disputes of Allah.
Hazrat Muavia [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq By Shaykh Mufti Taqi Usmani
Similarly, Banu A’bbas did the same to defame the Ummayyads. There is muadiya doubt that the incident of Karbala is a grave incident of our history. We should consider the following facts about these issues: Similarly, facts related to assassination of Bin Laden are also disputed.
This is the history and it cant be denied.
Hazrat Muavia r.a Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq By Shaykh Mufti Taqi Usmani
We should not accept all incidents reported to us by historians without such evaluation. He only compiled the traditions and did not perform evaluation of such reports.
However, information available through Tawatur is something different and exceptional. There is a discipline in the historical studies that deals with criticism on historical events.
Assalam o alaikum wa Rahmatullah. Because in this way you can say that Zia- ul-Haq ruled for 11 years because he was a very patient gaqaiq. You can check by yourselves in the “History of Tabari ” that all reports portraying a sleazy picture of the companions are reported by only five persons and all of them are considered as “liars “.
You know that muawiy theory means, “it might have happened “.
You can download and see through the taareekhi related to the years ranging from 30 to 65H. Dear Brother Assalam o alaikum wa Rahmatullah Thank you very much for answering me.
I’ll advise you to study that procedure and apply that on the original source of all historical narrations compiled by Tabari. I even extend this to all other people and do not accuse anyone for any charge against him and leave their matter to Allah. We know that some people are biased towards Hazrat Abu BakrU’mar.
Although mistakes at individual capacity was possible but how could you believe that all companions committed a great crime collectively while the evidence against them is nothing except statements of a few people whose reliability is already under question?
Mohadisin have devised a great procedure to evaluate authenticity ,uawiya Hadith. I’m not in a position to do so. Please see at least the Unit 1 of this book.
Hazrat Muawiya( R. A) Aur Tarikhi Haqaiq : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
Nobody engages in a revolt with a handful of companions including his family members and young children. He will decide this issue on the Day of Judgment. The unchallenged information could only be the one which is available to us by ” Tawatur please see the link below ” which is not sufficient to give us a complete picture of the incident.
Don’t hesitate to share your questions and comments. When the matter is only an issue of doubtful reports, why should we form our opinions based on them.